10.11.14

Access to the CA-News.org portal is blocked by the internet providers of Kazakhstan


The Association for Human Rights in Central Asia received a complaint about blocking of access to the CA-News.org portal in Kazakhstan.

Since July 2014 internet users of Almaty, Astana, Karaganda and other cities of Kazakhstan do not have a direct access to this internet portal; they have to use web-proxy services.

According to observations most of the providers such as Kazakhtelecom, Beeline-Kazakstan and others are blocking access to this portal.

CA-News.org was created in 2007. A network of reporters from Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan post 150-200 messages every day. This online publication covers new from 5 Central Asian countries raising sensitive and relevant topics. In the region with the population of 65 million, the web portal has about 400 thousand readers most of whom are in Kazakhstan..

The representatives of the providers and state institutions did not provide official explanations of the reasons for blocking  the access.

Freedom of expression and creation is guaranteed. Censorship is prohibited” – states the Constitution of Kazakhstan. – Everyone has a right to free access and circulation of information in any manner not prohibited by law”.

Jodgor Obid, a Vice-President of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia notes: "Central Asian providers systematically block access to web-sites which publish materials containing criticism of authorities. This practice can be overcome only by active involvement of international observers and community of journalists. It is important to provide not only technical support for the non-censored media, but also show public solidarity with them. Each of us needs to protect and exercise the right to freedom of expression of opinion and access reliable information".

The Association for Human Rights in Central Asia calls on the government of Kazakhstan to protect Constitutional rights of it citizens fulfil its obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

If you would like to post to show your solidarity, you can send you message to: news@ca-news.org, canews@asia.com

6.11.14

France-Uzbekistan: Secret meeting between French and Uzbek Foreign Affairs ministers

ACAT (Action by Christians for the Abolition of Torture)/ Association for Human Rights in Central Asia - Press release

Today and tomorrow, the Uzbek Minister of Foreign Affairs should meet discreetly Laurent Fabius, the French Minister of Foreign Affairs, as well French Senate and National Assembly members. ACAT and the Associationfor Human Rights in Central Asia express their surprise and deep concern regarding this secret meeting with the high representative of a regime in which torture is systematically used.

No information has been released on the official agenda of the French Minister of Foreign Affairs, or on the other French political institutions’. ACAT and the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia found out about this meeting only on the official agenda of the Uzbek Ministry. It reveals that an Uzbek delegation led by Minister of Foreign Affairs Abdulaziz Kamilov should meet his French counterpart, some members of the Senate and the National Assembly, as well as business representatives. Only International Medef, the French Business Confederation, announced this meeting.

According to Christine Laroque, Asia-Central Asia-Russia desk manager at ACAT, “The Uzbek dignitaries are rightly shunned by most western leaders. It is surprising and shocking that the highest French institutions organize today, in secret, such meetings. The silence surrounding this visit shows their political embarrassment as well as a clear lack of transparency from the political power to the civil society.

According to Nadejda Atayeva, president of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia, “Since Islam Karimov becam head of State 25 years ago, the Uzbek government is one of the worst torture and repressive regimes in the world. Torture is systematic in police custody and in prisons.” The United Nations Committee Against Torture (UNCAT) severely criticized Uzbekistan last year.

Dozens of human rights defenders, journalists and peaceful activists are held on politically-motivated grounds. Thousands of people are locked up simply for practicing their religion - Christians as well as
Muslims.

In 2013, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) stopped visiting prisoners in Uzbekistan because the government refuses to cooperate with ICRC standard procedures. Over the last 12 years, every United Nations expert has been denied access to the country to monitor the human rights situation. No international NGO is allowed since the expulsion of Human Rights Watch in 2011.

Uzbek activists take high risks to defend human rights, sometimes until death, like Abdurasul Hudoynazarov, a prisoner who was supported by ACAT for a long time. This activist, well-known for his work against corruption of police officers and security forces, spent 8 years in prison suffering from torture. Deprived of medical treatment and submitted to repeated abuses, his health severely deteriorated. He was released last May for medical grounds, before dying a few weeks later, on June 26th, the International Day in Support of Victims of Torture.

Since 2005, no independent investigation has been conducted and no one has been held accountable for the Andijan massacre, in which the security forces shot into crowds of mostly peaceful protestors, killing hundreds in that city. As a consequence, France along with other European Union (EU) countries put targeted sanctions on the Uzbek government between 2005 and 2009 that were linked  to improvements and respect of specific human rights criteria.

ACAT and the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia consider that such meetings involving economic negotiations and potentially strategic and military cooperation with French authorities should take place only when the Uzbek government will have proved credible evidence of its real intention to comply with human rights. ACAT and the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia urge French authorities at least to use this opportunity to express publicly and directly to the Uzbek Minister France’s concerns regarding the human rights situation in Uzbekistan.

Contacts presse:
• Pierre Motin, ACAT, +33 1 40 40 40 24 / +33 6 12 12 63 94, pierre.motin@acatfrance.fr
(English, French);
• Nadejda Atayeva, Association for Human Rights in Central Asia, +33 6 49 38 86 59, asiecentrale@neuf.fr (Russian)



Rajabboy Bobojon a journalist died in Uzbekistan

Rajabboy Bobojon 
On 5 November 2014 Rajabboy Bobojon passed away. He was born in 1937 and lived in city of Urgench of the Khorazm region of Uzbekistan all his life.

R. Bobojon worked for 40 years as a correspondent of Radio of Uzbekistan for the Khorazm region. He won the confidence of a large audience with his witty and relevant reports. In all his reports he always showed difficult life situations of ordinary citizens which resulted in him being perceived by the authorities as a dissident. People quote him when criticising the officials for their inaction.

Rajabboy Bobozhon was and will remain a role model for his children and grandchildren. His three sons Shukhrat, Kudrat and Hurmat Babajanovs became journalists and are being prosecuted by the Islam Karimov regime for their works. R. Bobojon always supported his sons’ professional position. The State TV channels of Uzbekistan many times showed libellous films about them. He was very proud for bringing them up to be independent and courageous in such closed and repressive society. Shukhrat, Kudrat and Khurmat Babajonovs had to leave Uzbekistan because of a threat of imprisonment. Their father was very sensitive to this forced separation.

Rajabboy Bobojon’s family always highly valued freedom of expression and opinions. The father even had to go through a forced separation from his sons and grandchildren for the love of these ideals. Shukhrat, Kudrat and Khurmat Babajonovs continued working as journalist abroad. Their loss is made even greater because the Karimov regime did not give them any chance to say goodbyes or give the last rites to their father.

The team and members of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia express their condolences to the family of Rajabboy Bobojonon.

We cherish his memories.


24.10.14

Kyrgyzstan: The Prosecutor’s Office took control over Azimjon Ibragimov’s case

The Osh City Prosecutor’s Office conducted a Supervisory Review of Azimjon Ibragimov’s complaint regarding an attack on him two months ago.

On 1 September 2014, at 05:30 AM, near the “Khasiyat” mosque of the Osh city, an ethnic Uzbek, Azimjon Ibragimov, born in 1951, was attacked. He was going to the mosque for the Morning Prayer. He was unexpectedly approached by three young Kyrgyz looking men who addressed him as “You Sart”; he then came under a sudden physical attack by them.

Azimjon Ibragimov sustained two broken ribs, a concussion and multiple bruises and was forced to seek medical care at the Department of Traumatology of Osh city hospital.

Soon Kyrgyz authorities found out about this attack on basis of the ethnic animosity. But the investigation really started only after intervention of the State Commission on National Policies and with assistance of “Freedom House”, “Human Right Watch”, the OSCE and other international organisations.

On 21 October 2014 the Chief Prosecutor E. Asratov of the Osh City Prosecutor’s Office said that he conducted a Supervisory Review of Alimzjon Ibragimov’s case instigated on his complaint about an attack on him and took the case under his control in accordance with Article 34 “Competence of the Prosecutor in conducting criminal matters” of the Criminal Procedural Code of the Republic of Kyrgyzstan.

The Association Human Rights in Central Asia expresses its gratitude to all the organisations who assisted Azimjon Ibragimov’s cause and hopes that the law enforcement agencies will do everything possible to bring the perpetrators to justice. 


14.10.14

Uzbekistan: a human rights activist Nuraddin Djumaniyazov is admitted to a hospital

Nuraddin Djumaniyazov, a jailed human rights activist is in dire health and suffers from diabetes. He was transferred to the Sangorod- УЯ 64/18, a prison medical facility in Tashkent. 

Nuraddin Djumaniyazov
Nuraddin Reimberganovich Djumaniyazov, was born on 8 October 1948 in Turtkul city of Karakalpakistan Autonomous Soviet Republic, Uzbekistan national, divorced, has got two children.  He is a member of the “Mazlum” human rights centre since 2003 and one of the founders. In 2012 he took an active part in founding the Union of Free Trade Unions to support the labour migrants and was a head of the Tashkent department. 

In January 2014, Djumaniyazov and other human rights defender, Fakhriddin Tillaev were accused of human trafficking under Article 135, Part 3, Subsection (d) of the Criminal Code of Republic of Uzbekistan. 

On 6 March 2014 the Tashkent City Shaykhontahur District Criminal Court sentenced him to 8 years and 9 months of imprisonment; Fakhriddinn Tillaev was sentenced to 10 years and 8 months.

Although the defence lawyer could demonstrate that during the investigative stage of the case and at the Court hearing the rights of Nuraddin Djumaniyazov and Fakhriddin Tillaev were violated, the appeals were unsuccessful.

Previous press releases about this case:
         - «Uzbekistan: the Supreme Court upheld the previous Court’s Decision against Tillaev and Djumaniyazov » dated 14 October 2014;
         - «Uzbekistan: the sentence against the human rights defenders Fakhriddin Tillaev and Nuraddin Djumanniyazov is upheld » dated 21 April 2014;
         - «Uzbekistan: Two human rights activists are imprisoned for 8 years and 3 months » dated 8 March 2014;
         - «Uzbekistan: A human rights activist Fakhriddin Tillaev is under a threat of long term imprisonment» dated 18 February 2014.

Uzbekistan: the Supreme Court upheld the Sentence against human rights activists Tillaev and Djumaniyazov

The Supreme Court of Uzbekistan has considered the appeal case of Fakhriddin Tillaev and Nuraddin Djumaniyazov, members of the “Mazlum” human rights centre. The Court Decision read that the guilt of the accused was proved by evidence, their conduct was a criminal one and the punishment proportionate.
Fakhriddin Tillaev
Fakhriddin Khabibullaevich Tillaev, was born on 15 August 1971, in the town of Baysun of the Surkhandarya region, Uzbekistan National, married and has two children. He is a member of the “Mazlum” human rights centre since 2003. He is involved in protection of labour rights in Surkhandarya region since 2005. In 2012, he was one of the founders of the Union of Free Trade Unions headed by Abdulla Tojiboy ogli, for support of the labour migrants.

Nuraddin Djumaniyazov
Nuraddin Reimberganovich Djumaniyazov, was born on 8 October 1948 in Turtkul city of Karakalpakistan Autonomous Soviet Republic, Uzbekistan national, divorced, has got two children. He is a member of the “Mazlum” human rights centre since 2003 and one of the founders. In 2012 he took an active part in founding the Union of Free Trade Unions to support the labour migrants and was a head of the Tashkent department.

The defence lawyer made an application to the Court asking for the case to be reviewed and the Judgement repealed. 
  • On 6 March 2014 the Tashkent City Shaykhantahur District Criminal Court sentenced two human rights activists, Fakhriddin Tillaev to 10 yours and 8 months of imprisonment and Nuraddin Djumaniyazov to 9 years, under Article 135 (Human Trafficking offence) of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The Court applied the Amnesty issued by the Senate to the case. 
  • On 17 April 2014 the Appeal Panel of the Tashkent City Court upheld the Judgement.
  • On 3 June 2014 an application was sent to the Tashkent City Court asking it to review the Judgement of the Shaykhantahur Criminal Court and the Decision of the Tashkent City Court Appeal Panel dated 17 April 2014. The application was rejected. 
The prosecution relied on assumptions. All the while, none of the Courts either checked the materials of the case or rectified numerous violations of the criminal procedure rules. 

An investigator of the Investigations Department of the Tashkent Department of Internal Affairs Office ignored the application requesting forensic examination of Fakhriddin Tillaev who was subjected to physical violence. The investigator saw the bruising on his body.  

Even long before the Court hearing the investigator did not hide his confidence that Tillaev and Djumaniyazov will be jailed. As his response to a number of repeat requests to conduct a forensic examination, in violation of the Criminal Procedural Code, he sent the application requesting the forensics to a Warden of the Tashkent Prison instead of a medical institution. It is still unclear whether there was a forensic examination and if so, what were the results. 

Further violations of the criminal procedure were unfounded rejections, first by the investigation then by the Court, to call Zhanar Demeuva, a Kazakhstan national, as a witness for the defence. Her evidence would allow assessing appearance of the victims F. Pardaev and E. Erdanov in Shimkent objectively. But this was not in the interests of either the Court or the investigation. The witness statements, which confirmed the prosecution’s case, were read out at the hearing. 

Additionally, the investigator claimed that because Zhanar Demeuova lives in Kazakhstan, he is unable to call her for giving evidence. Articles 592-593 of the Criminal Court of Uzbekistan says “… when it is necessary to carry out procedural steps provided for in this Code, in the territory of a foreign country, the Court, the Prosecutor and the Investigator put forward a request to competent authorities of a foreign state in accordance with international agreements signed by the Republic of Uzbekistan or on mutual basis”. However, these provisions were ignored by the investigation and the Court. 

In this manner, F. Tillaev and N. Djumaniyazov were found guilty under Subsection 2, Part 3 of Article 135 (Human Trafficking offence) of the Criminal Code of Uzbekistan, in violation of procedural rules. 

At the hearing, the place, time and manner of the crime allegedly committed by F. Tillaev were not established. 

Tillaev’s innocence is also proved by the fact that at the time when F. Pardaev and E. Erdanov were looking for work and at their departure he was in police detention for 15 for a non-criminal offence. 

The “victims” F. Pardaev and E. Erdanov sent a complaint to the Tashkent city Main Department of Internal Affairs Office alleging that they were smuggled into Kazakhstan where they were subjected to humiliation and threats. There is no supporting evidence for these allegations. A witness for prosecution Abdulla Tojiboy ogli also gave evidence. 

Thus the evidence produced by the prosecution is not conclusive; Fakhriddin Tillaev and Nuraddin Djumaniyazov were sentenced illegally. They were deprived of protection of their rights, appeal application was rejected. 

On 3 June 2014, the lawyer representing convicted human rights activists Fakhriddin Tillaev and Nuraddin Djuamniyazov, relying on Articles 510 (Persons Entitled to Bring Complaint against Sentence and Finding or Ruling by Way of Supervision Procedure) and 511 (Persons Entitled to Bring Protest against Sentence and Finding or Ruling in Court of Supervision) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan filed an Appeal Application against the Judgement of the Shaykhantahur District Criminal Court dated 6 March 2014 and Decision of the Tashkent City Court dated 17 April 2014. He requested to repeal the Judgement and the criminal case against F. Tillaev and N. Djumaniyazov to be dropped. However, the acting Chairman of Judicial Panel on Criminal Matters G. Hidoyatov upheld the Judgement. 

The Association for Human Rights in Central Asia is convinced that human rights activists Tillaev and Djumaniyazov are convicted on trumped-up charges, their efforts to have a just, objective trial of their case using the domestic means of protection have failed. The next step available to the convicted human rights activists to restore the justice is to appeal to the UN Committee on Human Rights.

13.10.14

Our Condolences

On 10 October, Hamda Talipova, mother of Dilmurad Said a jailed human rights activist of the “Ezgulik” Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan passed away.

Dear Dilmurad Said,
It hard to accept the news that you Mother Hamda Tolipova died. She had enormous belief in you and was very proud of you. We appreciate that her departure is a hard blow for you. 

We deeply mourn with you.
We cherish the  memory of Hamda Talipova.

Please accept our deepest condolences. ,
from the members and the team of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia