The Uzbekistani authorities continue to suppress the memory of the Andijan tragedy
Twenty years after the massacre in Andijan, victims and witnesses remain fearful of speaking out about the events that claimed hundreds of civilian lives, as the authorities continue to suppress the truth about the tragedy, the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA), the Norwegian Helsinki Committee (NHC) and International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) said in a statement today. The three organisations called on the Uzbekistani authorities to finally facilitate an independent and transparent investigation into the tragic events to ensure accountability and deliver justice to the many victims.
On 13 May 2005, thousands of protestors gathered in front of the Andijan regional administration building amid rumours that President Karimov would would arrive that day to meet with them. The crowd included supporters of 23 Andijan entrepreneurs who were on trial for extremism due to their alleged membership in the banned Akramiya organisation. Protesters also voiced broader grievances related to social issues and perceived misconduct by state officials. In response, law enforcement authorities used disproportionate and indiscriminate force, resulting in the deaths of hundreds of civilians. While official figures put the death toll at 187, refugees from Andijan estimate the number to be much higher. Following these events, thousands of people were reportedly forced into exile.
The international
community unanimously condemned the excessive violence used against protestors
in Andijan and called for an independent international investigation. This was
rejected by Tashkent. In response, the European Union imposed sanctions on
Uzbekistan, banning 12 officials from entering the EU, imposing an arms embargo,
and partially suspending its Partnership and Cooperation Agreement with
Uzbekistan. The sanctions were gradually eased over the following years before
being fully lifted in 2009. The US also condemned the Uzbekistani government's
actions in Andijan and closed its military base in Khanabad.
In the aftermath of
the Andijan events, the authorities launched a large-scale crackdown on civil
society, during which hundreds of witnesses to the events reportedly were
arrested for openly supporting calls for an independent international
investigation. By spring 2006, almost
40 human rights activists and journalists had been imprisoned on trumped-up
charges – a number that continued to grow in the subsequent period. The names of civil society activists and
political emigrants were reportedly listed by the security services alongside
the names of terrorists.
Most of those who
fled Uzbekistan after the Andijan events later lost their Uzbekistani
citizenship due to the government’s restrictive policies and have been unable
to regain it, although some have been allowed to visit the country for short
periods.
Even years after
the 2005 protests, former Andijan residents have been prosecuted and convicted
for their participation in the 2005 protests. For example, on 5 January 2023,
Kayumov Mukhamadvali was sentenced to over 15 years in prison on such charges. After
living in Sweden for 18 years, separated from his wife and children, he
returned to Uzbekistan based on assurances from the Uzbekistani embassy in
Sweden that it would be safe for him to do so.
When President
Mirziyoyev came to power in 2016, he ordered the release of dozens of imprisoned
civil society activists, journalists and others, and announced systemic reforms
to address past injustices and open up Uzbekistan to the international
community. President Mirziyoyev’s early steps ushered in a cautious optimism
and earned his regime an improved international image.
However, in recent years Uzbekistan has experienced backsliding on human rights and a shrinking space for freedom of expression and dissent. In this context, witnesses to the Andijan tragedy remain fearful of speaking out. At the same time, despite President Mirziyoyev’s pledges to address past injustices, authorities have yet to bring the perpetrators of the unlawful killings in Andijan to justice and still refuse to verify information about reported mass graves related to the events. They have taken no transparent steps to clarify the circumstances of the 2005 tragedy and continue to refuse calls from the international community to conduct an independent international investigation. Most of the human rights defenders and journalists who were imprisoned for documenting the Andijan events have not been rehabilitated, although released, and there are reports that security officials have threatened them with renewed arrest should they actively pursue this matter.
In another apparent attempt to avoid confronting the past, works are currently being carried out at the site of the Andijan events, with a business centre planned for Bobur square where the violence took place.
We are deeply concerned
that the current Uzbekistani administration has failed to address impunity for both
the 2005 abuses in Andijan and more recent gross violations – particularly the violent
suppression of mass protests in Karakalpakstan in July 2022, when at least 21
people died according to official figures, with unofficial sources estimating a
much higher toll. AHRCA, NHC and IPHR call on the Uzbekistani authorities to
take decisive action to thoroughly and impartially investigate these injustices
and ensure accountability– a crucial step toward building a society based on the
rule of law. The
three organisations also call on the international community, including the
European Union, to reaffirm their demands for justice – both for the atrocities
committed in Andijan and for the more recent deaths in Karakalpakstan.
