7.6.11

Once again, about EU grant to organization controlled by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva: new details and food for thoughts


We previously reported that the European Commission has allocated a grant of 3.7 Euro to a charitable organization controlled by the daughter of the Uzbek dictator Islam Karimov (see that press release in a separate file).


In the letter signed by Europa House in Uzbekistan and dated of 20 April 2011, it is stated that the European Union is cooperating with the Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children (RCSAC), which has been headed by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva since its very founding. The letter also reveals that in 2008, the Center was already awarded a grant from the EU’s Institution Building and Partnership Programme (IBPP). It is interesting to note that the mandate of this program is to support civil society initiatives. However, in consideration of whether RCSAC is indeed a civil society institution, it was actually created by government resolution, according to which RCSAC is to report directly to the Cabinet of Ministers.

It is also worth to note that the IBPP programme in Uzbekistan has a budget for 2011-2012 of only one million Euros, and that the size of individual grants should be within the range of 100,000-200,000 Euro. However, the organization controlled by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva was awarded as much as 3.7 million Euros – that is, over three times than the entire IBPP budget for the whole country. RCSAC was evidently given rather exceptional treatment in comparison to other NGOs, as the size of the funding it received was 13 times higher than the maximum allowable grant provided to individual NGOs.

Apparently, such grants limited to 200 thousand Euros were not satisfactory enough for Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva. And therefore, the European Commission had to seek additional funds, this time under the so called Action Program 2010, clearly planned specifically to meet the needs of the president’s daughter. According to this Program, 4.2 million Euros were allocated for assistance to Uzbekistan, the lion’s share (3.7 Euros) of which was clearly intended for the organization controlled by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva. The remaining scraps went to financing the “strengthening of the two-chamber parliament in Uzbekistan.” Moreover, the 3.7 million Euro grant to the organization controlled by Karimova-Tillyaeva, again was categorized under the program “assistance to civil society in Uzbekistan”.

As we noted earlier, when most of the initiative NGOs in Uzbekistan were shuttered from 2004- 2010, through a campaign to stifle civil society associations, RCSAC, like other pseudo-NGOs created by the government, have become a monopoly in their sector, and thus the only organizations eligible and able to obtain grants from the European Commission and other international donors.

According to a study conducted by the Eurasia Foundation, from 2004 to 2007, 313 NGOs had to close down under the pressure from the state authorities (the full list is attached in Russian). Among them were NGOs specializing in working with children and disabled persons (in total, 14 such NGOs were closed), youth (8 NGOs closed), women (34), and medicine (7) - they are listed at the end of this press release. None of these NGOs have a chance anymore to receive grants from the European Commission, nor can they even exist or work as associations of citizens.  Even were they able to maintain their registration status, they would nonetheless not be able to receive foreign grants, as from 2004 there has been put into implementation a draconian licensing mechanism for transferring grant funds to the bank accounts of NGOs. Such a license can only be issued by a special commission at the Central Bank, which is virtually controlled by the National Security Service. 

Needless to say, the organizations patronized by the daughters of the Uzbek dictator do not know about such issues faced by ordinary civil society organizations. Moreover, these exclusive GONGOs seem to receive exclusive gifts from the European Union.

We are not opposed to the European Union’s generous allocation of assistance to Uzbek children. However, we urge the European Commission to recognize this for what it is. In other words, it should not qualify such grants, allocated to the representatives of corrupt regime that stifles civic freedoms in Uzbekistan, as assistance to civil society.

It would be more honest to call this program by another name – a program to support the PR of the daughters of Islam Karimov, as we doubt that these funds won’t be further used by Karimov family for self-promotion and generous gifts to European movie and pop stars.


Appendix

Some categories of NGOs, liquidated in Uzbekistan during 2004- 2007, as part of campaign to suppress civil society (the full list is in a separate attachment):

Children and disabled NGOs:
  1. Andizhan Club of Invalids’ parents “KRIDI”
  2. Bukhara Regional for Supporting Children of Invalids “Orzu”
  3. Centre of Women and Children - Invalids (Dzhizak)
  4. Children's Centre “Semourg “, Kokand 
  5. Tashkent Centre of Women and Children “Sabot” (Tashkent region)
  6. Fund of Children-Invalids (Karakalpakstan)
  7. Rehabilitation Centre of Children-Invalids (Karakalpakstan)
  8. Fund of Assistance to Children- Invalids (Samarkand region)
  9. Centre of Support of Women and Children-Invalids (Syr-Darya region)
  10. Association of Sportsmen-Invalids (Tashkent region)
  11. NGO “Aridi” (Karakalpakstan)
  12. NGO “KRIDI” (Karakalpakstan)
  13. Centre “Nekuz “ (Kashkadarya)
  14. Invalids Rehabilitation Centre “Umid” (Samarkand region)

Youth NGOs:
  1. Youth Centre “Iqbol” (Tashkent region)  
  2. Youth Centre “Maksad” (Khorezm region)
  3. Centre “Yoshlar kanoti” (Surkhandarya region)
  4. Centre “Barkamol avlod” (Surkhandarya region)
  5. Centre of youth initiatives “Jaslar” (Karakalpakstan)
  6. Youth Centre “Oltyn Kabutlar” (Samarkand region)
  7. College of Youth Problems (Surkhandarya region)
  8. Crisis Centre “Source” (Samarkand region)

Women NGO:
  1. Consulting Centre of Women-Lawyers “Family and Law” (Samarkand region)
  2. Centre of Confidence “Аёл ва Замон” (Andizhan region)
  3. Centre of Support of Women “Марварид” (Andizhan region)
  4. Cntre of Business Women and Craftswomen “El-Ayol “ (Andizhan region)
  5. Women Resource Centre (Bukhara region)
  6. NGO “School of housewives” (Karakalpakstan)
  7. NGO “Women and Aral children” (Karakalpakstan)
  8. NGO “Woman and health” (Karakalpakstan)
  9. Women Resource Centre (Kashkadarya region)
  10. NGO “Women In progress” (Kashkadarinskai region)
  11. Centre of Support of Women “Azizs” (Khorezm region)
  12. Women Centre “Yangi Khayot” (Khorezm region)
  13. Women Centre “Ikhlos” (Khorezm region)
  14. Women Centre “Marjon” (Khorezm region)
  15. Women Society “Orom” (Khorezm region)
  16. Women Centre “Mansura” (Khorezm region)
  17. Civic Centre of Women Initiatives (Khorezm region)
  18. Women Centre “Najot” (Khorezm region)
  19. Women Centre “Umida “ (Namangan region)
  20. Women Centre “Sharq Guzali” (Namangan region)
  21. Union of women-leaders “Сардор” (Navoi)
  22. Women Centre “Zebuniso” (Navoi)
  23. Women Centre “Umida” (Navoi)
  24. Women Centre “Мавтуна” (Navoi)
  25. Centre of social adaptation of women Navoi region
  26. Centre “Oila “ (Navoi)
  27. Centre of Women-Leaders “Sardor” (Navoi)
  28. Samarkand Region Union of Women NGOs(Samarkand region)
  29. Centre for Protection of  Rights and Interests of Women (Samarkand region)
  30. Tashkent Centre of Women-Leaders (Tashkent region) 
  31. Centre “Gender - Innovations and progress” (Tashkent region)
  32. Women Centre “Mekhri” (Tashkent region)
  33. NGO “Mehnatkash Ayol” (Tashkent region)
  34. Club of Women-Invalids “Intilish” (Tashkent region)

Medical NGOs
  1. Association of Young Physicians (Bukhara region)
  2. Centre “Avicena” (Fergana region)
  3. Association of Doctors-Volunteers “Revival” (Navoi)
  4. Association of Medical Students (Samarkand region)
  5. “Lainus Poling”  Centre of  Medical Information (Samarkand Region)
  6. Centre for Psychological and Legal Assistance “ Mehr Yogdusi” (Tashkent region)
  7. Centre for Social Adaptation and Reproductive Health (Tashkent region)

To the Prosecutor General of the Republic of Kazakhstan Mr. Ashat Daulbayev

June 7, 2011

To the Prosecutor General of the Republic of Kazakhstan
Mr. Ashat Daulbayev

The Prosecutor General of the Republic of Kazakhstan
8, Orynbor St., House of Ministries, Entrance
№ 2010000 Astana
Republic of Kazakhstan

Via facsimile: +7 7172 50-25-34


Dear Ashat Kaizullayevich:

We, the undersigned international human rights organizations, are writing to express our grave concern about the possible extradition to Uzbekistan of 32 Uzbeks—two of whom are Tajik nationals—currently in custody in Almaty, Kazakhstan where they had sought asylum. We are of the firm belief that these men are at a real risk of torture if returned to Uzbekistan and therefore, according to Kazakhstan’s obligations under international law, may not be returned to Uzbekistan.

Kazakhstan is bound by international law, including by the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees and its 1967 protocol, and the Convention against Torture, to respect the principle of non-refoulement. Thus, Kazakhstan is prohibited from extraditing or otherwise forcibly returning individuals to places where their lives or freedoms may be threatened or where they face a risk of torture.

In December 2010, ACAT France submitted a complaint to the United Nations Committee against Torture on behalf of 29 Uzbeks to prevent their extradition to Uzbekistan. Three other asylum seekers were subsequently detained. On December 24, 2010 the Committee against Torture imposed interim measures to stay extradition pending review of merits of the complaint. The government of Kazakhstan subsequently challenged the admissibility of the complaint. On May 6, 2011 the Committee reaffirmed the interim measures, prohibiting Kazakhstan from extraditing these individuals, pending the Committee’s review.

As stated above, Kazakhstan has an absolute obligation not to return anyone to a country where he or she faces a real risk of torture. Thus, under no circumstances may Kazakhstan extradite or otherwise return the 32 men to Uzbekistan. A violation of this obligation or of the interim measures imposed by the Committee against Torture would constitute a serious breach of Kazakhstan’s obligations under international law and call into question Kazakhstan’s willingness to respect its international commitments.

According to interviews conducted by FIDH with some of the men prior to their arrest, and information received from relatives and other asylum-seekers, the individuals facing extradition are Muslims who fled Uzbekistan fearing persecution based on their religious affiliation, beliefs, and practices, and membership or suspected membership in unregistered Islamist organizations. Kazakh authorities detained the men on the basis of extradition requests issued by the Uzbekistan government for alleged anti-state and religion-related offenses, such as attempt to undermine the constitutional order and membership in banned or unregistered organizations.

For well over a decade, authorities in Uzbekistan have waged an unrelenting campaign of persecution against Muslims who practice their faith outside strict state controls or who belong to unregistered religious organizations with thousands incarcerated for non-violent offenses.  Human rights organizations have documented numerous, widespread cases of torture and other ill-treatment, arbitrary detention, and deaths in custody of individuals accused of anti-state and religion-related crimes in Uzbekistan.  Methods of torture and other ill-treatment have included electric shock, beatings with truncheons, rape and other sexual abuse, asphyxiation, and psychological abuse, including threats to harm a detainee’s relatives.

Uzbekistan’s record on torture and ill-treatment of pre-trial detainees and prisoners has also been documented by UN bodies, including the-then UN special rapporteur on Torture, Theo van Boven, who in 2003 found torture in Uzbekistan to be “systematic,” and the UN Committee against Torture, which after its periodic review of Uzbekistan in 2007, found that torture in places of detention in Uzbekistan is “routine” and occurs “with impunity.” In addition, the European Court of Human Rights has issued multiple rulings prohibiting states from returning persons to Uzbekistan on the basis of a risk of torture.  Most recently, on November 4, 2010, in Sultanov v Russia (No. 15303/09), the court held that “forcible return to Uzbekistan would give rise to a violation of Article 3” [of the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms] as there would be a “a serious risk of being subjected to torture or inhuman and degrading treatment.”

In the past, Kazakhstan has blatantly violated its absolute obligation not to return to torture. On May 30, 2011, Kazakh authorities extradited Ershidin Israil, an Uighur refugee, to China, where he faces a real risk of torture. In September 2009, Israil fled to Kazakhstan seeking asylum after the July 2009 Urumqi riots in the Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region of China, in which over 200 people were killed. Hundreds of Uighurs were detained after the violence in Urumqi, and several people have been executed for involvement in the rioting. 

In March 2010, UNHCR granted Israil refugee status, but Kazakh authorities prevented him being resettled to Sweden by denying him necessary exit documents. UNHCR later revoked his status.  Then, in June 2010, Kazakh authorities took Israil into custody. Israil was denied refugee status under Kazakhstan’s new law on refugees, and on May 30, 2011, he was handed over to Chinese authorities, who had reportedly accused Israil of involvement in “terrorism.” His whereabouts are currently unknown.

Despite the well-documented evidence that the use of torture in Uzbekistan is widespread and systematic, since September 2010, Kazakhstan has also forcibly returned to Uzbekistan at least four individuals, two of whom are not citizens of Uzbekistan, associated with the group of 32 detainees. On September 8, 2010, Kazakh authorities extradited Khurshid Kamilov, a citizen of Kyrgyzstan and ethnic Uzbek, to Uzbekistan. On September 27, Kazakhstan extradited Saidakhmad Kholmatov (b. 1974), an Uzbek citizen whose asylum claim was still under review, to Uzbekistan.  On October 30, 2010, before he could contest in court the decision denying him asylum, authorities extradited to Uzbekistan Umarali Abdurakhmanov (b. 1975), an ethnic Uzbek from Tajikistan who was detained in early 2010 in Taraz, Kazakhstan. On November 10, 2010, Rasul Rakhmonov (b. 1987), an Uzbek citizen, was also extradited to Uzbekistan. His asylum claim was under review at the time of his extradition. An Uzbek court sentenced Abdurakhmonov to 10 years’ imprisonment on January 27, 2011.  According to the verdict, Abdurakhmonov categorically denied the charges against him and said that the investigator made him sign several papers, saying “you committed these acts, sign the papers.” None of the signatories to this letter have been able to confirm the whereabouts of the other three.

Previously, in 2006, Kazakh authorities forcibly returned a UNHCR mandate refugee Gabdurafih Temirbaev, to Uzbekistan. He had fled religious persecution in his country and was subsequently detained by Kazakh authorities. In 2008, Kazakhstan also extradited Rafik Rakhmonov, who sought asylum in Kazakhstan after the Andijan massacre, in violation of its international obligations.

In light of the fact that the 32 Uzbek and Tajik nationals in detention and in extradition proceedings face a real risk of torture if returned to Uzbekistan, we urge the authorities of Kazakhstan, in the strongest possible terms, to uphold its non-derogable, international obligation not to forcibly return any of these men to Uzbekistan, and to cease or reverse extradition proceedings or rulings in relation to them.

We also wish to convey our concern about the fairness of appellate hearings contesting the extradition orders and refusals of asylum with respect to the 32 Uzbeks currently in detention.

All 32 had requested asylum from Kazakh authorities under Kazakhstan’s new Law on Refugees, which entered into force in January 2010.  Many of the provisions of this law fail to comply with international law, such as the provision allowing for the refusal of asylum on the basis that the applicant is a member of a banned religious organization in his or her country of origin.

While Kazakh authorities have allowed the detained asylum seekers access to lawyers to represent them in judicial proceedings, the appellate process has been marred by serious due process violations.

Independent observers, including representatives of the OSCE and Human Rights Watch, attended appellate hearings contesting the denials of asylum status in December 2010. In some cases, judges rejected detainees’ motions to attend their own hearings, effectively preventing them from presenting any evidence on their own behalf.  Judges also refused to admit into evidence reports by the UN and human rights organizations about the widespread practice of torture in Uzbekistan, in particular, against individuals charged with religion-related offenses.  In at least one hearing, the presiding judge dismissed the testimony of one of the detainee’s wives, who described harassment and torture she and her husband had experienced at the hands of Uzbek authorities, saying that there was no way to confirm her allegations.

Appellate hearings have occurred in quick succession, with judges issuing rulings in writing after only brief consideration, in some cases lasting as few as 15 minutes.  At the close of one hearing, the judge began to read aloud a decision affirming the denial of refugee status for another asylum-seeker whose appellate hearing had not yet taken place, giving rise to the legitimate apprehension that the outcome of each of the hearings for all detained asylum seekers was predetermined.

Kazakh authorities have also created barriers for the wives of the detained asylum-seekers to apply separately for refugee status, impeding their right to an individualized, thorough and careful refugee status determination. To date, it is unclear whether Kazakh authorities will treat the family members of the detained asylum-seekers as separate cases or whether the wives and children of the detainees could be forcibly returned together with their husbands. 

ACAT-France , Amnesty International, the Association “Human Rights in Central Asia,” Human Rights Watch, and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH), urgently call on the Kazakh government to respect the interim measures issued by the UN Committee against Torture and prevent any further forced returns of any asylum-seekers to Uzbekistan.  Furthermore, Kazakh authorities should ensure that each detained asylum-seeker and his immediate family members are given prompt access to careful, thorough, and individualized refugee status determination in which their due process rights are protected.

We thank you for your attention to the concerns raised in this letter and look forward to receiving your response.

Sincerely,

ACAT-France
Amnesty International
The Association “Human Rights in Central Asia”
Human Rights Watch
International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH)


Uzbek Detainees Currently under Threat of Extradition to Uzbekistan

1.      Toirjon Abdusamatov (b. 1974)
2.      Faizullohon Akbarov (b. 1990)
3.      Akhmad Boltaev (b. 1968)
4.      Shukhrat Botirov (b. 1986)
5.      Sukhrob Bozorov (b. 1978)
6.      Mukhiddin Guliamov (b. 1967)
7.      Dilbek Karimov (b. 1987)
8.      Shukhrat Kholboev (b. 1973)
9.      Olimzhon Kholturaev (b. 1975)
10.  Alisher Khoshimov (b. 1969)
11.  Sarvar Khuramov (b. 1983)
12.  Abror Kosimov (b. 1983)
13.  Oibek Kuldashev (b. 1982)
14.  Sunnatullokh Kuldashev (b. 1985)
15.  Sukhrob Kuldashev (b. 1988)
16.  Kobildzhon Kurbonov (b. 1966)
17.  Bakhriddin Nurullaev (b. 1971)
18.  Bakhtiyor Nurullaev (b. 1983)
19.  Ulugbek Ostonov (b. 1973)
20.  Isobek Pardaev (b. 1987)
21.  Oibek Pulatov (b. 1987)
22.  Uktam Rakhmatov (b. 1989)
23.  Otabek Sharipov (b. 1978)
24.  Sherzod Shernazarov (b. 1978)
25.  Akmalzhon Shodiev (b. 1977, Tajik national)
26.  Tursunboi Sulaimonov (b. 1976, Tajik national)
27.  Sirozhiddin Tolipov (b. 1986)
28.  Ravshan Turaev (b. 1969)
29.  Faiziddin Umarov (b. 1978)
30.  Abduazimkhudzha Yakubov (b. 1982)
31.  Maruf Yuldoshev (b. 1990)
32.  Saidakbar Zhalolkhonov (b. 1974)


CC:
Mr. Juan Mendez, United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Forms of Cruel, Inhuman, and Degrading Treatment
Committee Members, United Nations Committee Against Torture and Other Forms of Cruel, Inhuman, and Degrading Treatment
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
Chargé d’Affaires of the United States a.i. John Ordway
Ambassador David Moran, Embassy of the United Kingdom
Ambassador Jean-Charles Berthonnet, Embassy of France
Ambassador Rainer Schlageter, Embassy of Germany
Mr. Yerzhan Kazykhanov, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Republic of Kazakhstan
Mr. Askar Shakirov, National Ombudsman of the Republic of Kazakhstan



Kazakhstan: Don’t Extradite Uzbeks to Torture

Respect International Obligations 



(Paris, June 7, 2011) – Kazakh authorities should not extradite 32 detainees to Uzbekistan, where they face a real risk of torture,  ACAT-France, Amnesty International, the Association “Human Rights in Central Asia,” Human Rights Watch, and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) said today.  The 32 men, who came to Kazakhstan seeking asylum from religious persecution in Uzbekistan, are at risk of torture and ill-treatment if they are forcibly returned to Uzbekistan, the groups said.

In a joint letter to Kazakhstan’s prosecutor general on June 7, 2011, the five human rights groups urged the government to respect its binding international obligation not to return any person to a country where he or she faces a risk of torture or other ill-treatment. Kazakhstan should comply with the United Nations Committee Against Torture’s (CAT) interim measures directing the government to refrain from extraditing 29 of the asylum-seekers, pending the committee’s review of the case. Since CAT imposed interim measures, Kazakh authorities have detained three others.

Returning a person to a country where there is a real risk that the person will be tortured is a serious breach of international law, the groups said.  

“It’s no secret that torture is systematic in Uzbekistan,” said Steve Swerdlow, Uzbekistan researcher at Human Rights Watch. “Given the criminal charges on which Uzbek authorities are seeking their extradition, the Kazakh government has an absolute duty not to send these men back to torture.”

According to interviews conducted by FIDH with some of the men prior to their arrest, and information received from relatives and fellow asylum-seekers, the 32 Uzbeks, two of whom are Tajik nationals, are Muslims who fled Uzbekistan fearing religious persecution. They are wanted by Uzbek authorities on various anti-state and religion-related charges.

In a December 2010 letter to the prosecutor general of Kazakhstan, Human Rights Watch described how Uzbeks charged with religion-related offenses have routinely been tortured. Since the detention of the majority of the 32 men in June 2010, ACAT-France, Amnesty International, the Association “Human Rights in Central Asia,” and the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) have also called upon the Kazakh government to uphold its obligation not to return individuals to a risk of torture.

For well over a decade, Uzbek authorities have waged an unrelenting campaign of persecution against independent Muslims whose practices, beliefs, and affiliations fall outside government restrictions. Human rights organizations have documented especially harsh police treatment, often including torture and other mistreatment of people accused of religion-related crimes.

Uzbekistan’s record of torture and ill-treatment of pre-trial detainees and prisoners has been documented by UN bodies. Theo van Boven, then the UN special rapporteur on torture, in 2003 found torture in Uzbekistan to be “systematic.” The UN CAT, after its periodic review of Uzbekistan in 2007, found that torture in detention in Uzbekistan is “routine” and occurs “with impunity.”

Methods of torture and other ill-treatment have included electric shock, beatings with truncheons, rape and other sexual abuse, asphyxiation, and psychological abuse, including threats to harm a detainee’s relatives.

“It is crystal clear: if any of these men are forcibly returned to Uzbekistan, they will face a grave risk of torture and ill-treatment,” said Christine Laroque, Asia programs manager at ACAT-France. “Kazakhstan should respect the UN interim measures and prevent their forced return at all costs.”

Forcibly returning any of the 32 detained men to Uzbekistan would violate the absolute prohibition on the return of persons to places where they risk torture, as stated in the Convention against Torture and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which Kazakhstan ratified in 1998 and 2006, respectively.

“International human rights treaties to which Kazakhstan is party trump any bilateral or regional agreements between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan,” said Maisy Weicherding, Amnesty International's expert on Central Asia. “No individual, regardless of his status, may be returned to a country where he or she faces a risk of torture.”

Kazakhstan has previously violated the principle of non-refoulement, or forced returns of refugees. On May 30, 2011, Kazakh authorities extradited to China Ershidin Israil, a Uighur refugee who had fled to Kazakhstan after the July 2009 Urumqi riots, in which over 200 people were killed. Hundreds of Uighurs were detained after the violence in Urumqi, and several people have been executed for involvement in the rioting. Israil was denied refugee status by Kazakh authorities, despite the clear risk of torture he would face if returned to China. In the past, Kazakh authorities have repeatedly forcibly returned Uighurs to China, where they are at risk of torture and the death penalty.

Kazakhstan has similarly violated the principle of non-refoulement with respect to Uzbekistan. From September to November 2010, Kazakh authorities unlawfully extradited to Uzbekistan four asylum-seekers: Khurshid Kamilov, Saidakhmad Kholmatov, Umarali Abdurakhmanov, and Rasul Rakhmanov. Abdurakhmanov was subsequently sentenced to 10 years in prison by an Uzbek court.    

In 2006, Kazakh authorities forcibly returned Gabdurafih Temirbaev, who had fled religious persecution in Uzbekistan, and at least nine other Uzbek nationals. In 2008, Kazakh authorities unlawfully extradited Rafik Rakhmonov, who sought asylum in Kazakhstan after the Andijan massacre.

“Kazakhstan has repeatedly failed to respect the non-refoulement principle but that must end,” said Amandine Regamey, member of the FIDH International Board.  “As the most recent chair of the OSCE Kazakhstan should be setting an example for other states to respect international treaties they have joined.”

One asylum-seeker who arrived in Kazakhstan under similar circumstances was eventually released and received provisional refugee status under the new Kazakh Law on Refugees, which entered into force in January 2010. But the 32 who remain in detention were all refused refugee status under the new law. The law itself has been criticized by human rights groups as failing to conform to international human rights and refugee law.

The decision to deny refugee status to the men has been upheld repeatedly on appeal by Almaty courts. These hearings have been marred by serious due process violations, raising concern about the overall fairness of the appellate process, the groups said.

The organizations also called on Kazakh authorities to provide each detainee and his family members a careful, thorough, and individualized asylum determination consistent with international standards. 

“The fact that some judges summarily refused even to consider Uzbekistan’s well-documented record of torture raises serious concerns about the overall fairness of the appellate process for these asylum-seekers,” said Nadejda Atayeva, president of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia. 

Background
Most of the 32 people in detention were taken into custody during raids in early June 2010, by Kazakh migration police and plain-clothes agents believed to be from the Committee for National Security (KNB).  Authorities later detained others in Almaty, Taraz, and Satpaev. Three have been detained since January.

About half the asylum-seekers are being held in National Security Agency (KNB) custody in Almaty, and others are in the custody of the Almaty City Jail of the Penitentiary System Committee (KUIZ).

Seventeen of them had been granted refugee status by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), but it withdrew their refugee status following their arrest and detention.


For more Human Rights Watch reporting on Kazakhstan, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/europecentral-asia/kazakhstan


For more Human Rights Watch reporting on Uzbekistan, please visit:
http://www.hrw.org/en/europecentral-asia/uzbekistan

For more FIDH reporting on Kazakhstan, please visit:

1.6.11

The European Union has allocated a grant of 3,7 million Euro to an organization controlled by the daughter of Uzbek dictator

Will it not be spent on another party of celebrities?

The European Union has allocated 3.7 million Euro to a charitable organization controlled by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva, the daughter of the Uzbek dictator. Karimova-Tillaeva is also Uzbekistan’s representative to UNESCO.

On 19 May 2011, in his defense statement in the suit brought by Lola Karimova against  the French online publication "Rue89," lawyer Antoine Germain mentioned a letter sent by the office of Europa House in Uzbekistan to the Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children (hereinafter – Center), the director of which is the Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva. The letter confirms that the European Union has allocated 3.7 million Euro to the Center, which will be transferred to its accounts in 2011. The letter from Europa House, dated 20 April 2011, was probably intended to attest to the respectability of Madame Karimova to the court in Paris.

At the same court proceedings, the journalist Anaelle Verzaux served as a witness presenting the cost estimates for a charity event organized by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva in February 2010 at the Versailles Palace. According to these estimates, this organization, run by Lola Karimova, paid 230,000 Euro for the attendance of the well-known actress Monica Bellucci at the party. It was not reported whether the guests to the party gave even one Euro to the fund for Uzbek children. Expenses were incurred only by Lola Karimova-Tillyaeva, but obviously not from her personal pocket.

This raises several questions:

1. First of all, we are concerned that funds allocated by the European Union and other foreign donors may be used for purposes other than their originally stated one, which may include for Lola Karimova’s self-promotion and for promotion of the autocratic regime which she represents.

These concerns are bolstered by the fact that information about the Center’s activities are not posted on the website of the organization itself (as there is no such site), but on the personal site of Lola Karimova-Tillaeva (http://www.lolakarimova.cz).

2. Does the European Union understand the nature and circumstances of the Center, to which it has given a significant amount of funding?

If the European Union believes that the Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children is a true representative of civil society in Uzbekistan, then they are seriously mistaken.

In Uzbekistan, the majority of non-governmental organizations, created by citizens themselves, including those aiming to help children with disabilities, were shuttered in 2004- 2006 in a campaign to crackdown civil society associations. This was the Uzbek regime’s reaction to the “color revolutions” that were taking place in some CIS countries. Only in August and September 2005, under the threat of criminal investigation, some 200 NGOs were forced to shut down. But even during the time that they were operating, not one civil society organization could even dream of receiving such a generous amount as 3,7 million Euro. Obviously, you have to be close to the presidential family in order to receive such an amount.

In Uzbekistan, in order to establish control over the population, the government itself created NGOs, known as GONGOs, which, unlike genuinely initiative civic associations, registered without a hitch, and are able to operate freely under favorable conditions.

The Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children was created exactly in such a manner, according to the Decree of the Cabinet of Ministers № 419, dated 7.09.2004. We’d highlight the following paragraphs from this decree: 

1. To develop through the Women’s Committee of Uzbekistan, a Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children [For your reference: the Women’s Committee – is, in practice, a state body, headed by the Deputy Prime Minister.]

2. To ensure that the director of the Center is approved by the Cabinet of Ministers and that his/her activities will be held accountable to the Cabinet of Ministers.

5. To include the Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children in:
- the list of organizations receiving copies of decrees and orders of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan, decrees and orders of the Cabinet of Ministers, and materials of the sessions of the Oliy Mazhilis [parliament] of the Republic of Uzbekistan;
- the list of recipients of bulletins of statistical information from the Ministry of Economics and the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Uzbekistan.

8. Women’s Committee of Uzbekistan will within two weeks, in consultation with the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of the Population, and the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Uzbekistan, approve a plan for the salaries of staff of the Center and a unified tax rate.

9. Tashkent City administration, will, within one month, allocate a building for the Republican Center for Social Adaptation of Children, providing the necessary conditions for its activities and operations, and will provide, if necessary, repairs to the premises, as well as telephone services.

10. Monitoring the implementation of this Decree will be assigned to the Deputy Prime Minister of the Republic of Uzbekistan S.T. Inamova.

That is how the regime imitates the existence of civil society in Uzbekistan and urges foreign donors to fund pseudo-NGOs created by it. At the same time, the activities of civic associations that have not received legal registration are seen as a violation of the law, and those who participate in such activities can be subject to serious repercussions.

There are also questions for the actress Monica Bellucci. Mrs. Bellucci, upon taking money from Lola Karimova, were you aware of the fact that the money given to you came from the budget of a charitable organization, which was supposed to provide assistance to children with disabilities? By giving this money to you, Lola Karimova deprived hundreds of children in need with the possibility of receiving much needed assistance. If you were not aware then, do you realize this now? What will you now do with these funds?

From the recent court hearings of Lola Karimova’s claims against the publication “Rue89,” it seems that Mrs. Karimova is very concerned of the dictatorial regime’s image, tarnished by this publication’s very competent journalists, and seeks to clean it up or “launder” it, so to speak, as a French journalist said. However, new circumstances make one wonder whether it’s not only the regime’s image that is being “laundered”, and whether the funds which were intended to help children with disabilities were ‘laundered’ too?

As the financial activities of the state and quasi-state structures in Uzbekistan are not a model of transparency, one can imagine that a generous grant from the European Union could be used to satisfy the personal aims of Lola Karimova or pay for expensive gifts to European celebrities.

Finally, the case of Karimova is a clear cut case of a conflict of interest. It is obvious that the appointment of Lola Karimova to a diplomatic post is either a result of the orders of her father – the dictator Islam Karimov, or was a decision made to curry his favor. The European Union must take this into account when such a considerable amount of funding is allocated to representatives of Uzbekistan’s corrupt regime.  



Association Droit de l’Homme en Asie Centrale
Centre MBE 140, 16, rue de Docteur Leroy, 72000 LE MANS FRANCE
Tel.:  +33 6 49 38 86 59; E-Mail: asiecentrale@neuf.fr