7.6.22

There is no excuse — criminalization of consensual sex between men in Uzbekistan is a human rights violation


Read the report in English, Russian, and Uzbek.

The Uzbekistani authorities should swiftly decriminalize consensual sex between men, according to the conclusions of a new report published today by the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA), the Eurasian Coalition on Health, Rights, Gender and Sexual Diversity (ECOM) and International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR). The groups say that it is imperative for Uzbekistan to make progress toward enshrining its international human rights commitments into law at this time, while a new draft Criminal Code is still under consideration.

Article 120 of the Criminal Code of Uzbekistan punishes consensual sexual relations between men by up to three years’ imprisonment. While an increasing number of countries around the world protect lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, intersex and queer people from discrimination and have outlawed punishment for same-sex relations, the report Like living on a different planet: Gays, bisexual men and trans people vulnerable to abuse, imprisonment and discrimination in Uzbekistan demonstrates that lesbians, gays, bisexual and trans people (LGBT) in Uzbekistan are at constant risk of serious human rights violations without any possible recourse to justice. Uzbekistan is one of only two former Soviet countries that have not decriminalised homosexuality.
     
In Uzbekistan, the criminalization of consensual sexual relations between men, widespread societal and religious homo- and transphobia, Russian policy influence and anti-Western sentiment amount to a toxic mix for LGBT people. 
         
A young gay man from Uzbekistan summed up the situation of LGBT people in his country: “It’s as if we lived on a different planet, where it is normal to hate, imprison, discriminate and kill people simply for who they are.”
        
“International human rights law makes it very clear that the criminalization of same-sex relations between consenting adults is a human rights violation. United Nations treaty bodies have repeatedly called on Uzbekistan to repeal Article 120 from the Criminal Code,” said Anne Sunder-Plassmann of IPHR.
      
Information submitted to IPHR by the National Centre for Human Rights of Uzbekistan (NCHR) and the Ombudsperson for Human Rights of the Oliy Majlis (Legislative Chamber of Parliament) in January and February 2022 respectively indicates that 36 persons were convicted under the Article in 2021, 25 of them to terms of imprisonment.
    3 logo 
However, these statistics represent only the mere tip of the iceberg and, in reality, many more people live under the looming threat of Article 120 in their daily lives. Our joint report documents police exploitation of the criminalization of homosexuality and the societal shame associated with it in order to threaten and intimidate gay and bisexual men with imprisonment and to extort money from them in exchange for not opening a criminal case or for not informing his relatives, neighbours or employers of his sexual orientation. The report also documents a pattern of police using torture and ill-treatment against gay and bisexual men in order to punish and humiliate them and to “persuade” them to pay a large bribe to regain their freedom. Under orders from Internal Affairs officials, doctors allegedly frequently conduct anal examinations to detect “evidence” of homosexual intercourse, despite the fact that they amount to ill-treatment and are “futile” and “unscientific”, according to the World Medical Association.
 
Ravshan, a young bisexual man, recalled how police treated him after detaining him: “They suspended me from the ceiling using handcuffs, beat me severely, and tried to rape me with a truncheon.” After that, police officers laid Ravshan on the floor and an officer jumped up and down on his stomach. Ravshan said: “I have never been beaten and intimidated like that in my entire life. I wanted to die to free myself from this torture”. When police threatened to imprison him under Article 120 unless he gave them 2000 USD, he paid up and was released.
 
The report also demonstrates that police often have access to the personal information of gay and bisexual men who are registered at HIV treatment centres.
 
“Gay and bisexual men who turn to HIV centres for treatment cannot be sure that their personal information will stay confidential. We have documented cases where HIV centre staff have informed the police of the man’s sexual orientation, putting him at risk of persecution. This is a violation of the right to privacy and poses a major obstacle to accessing much needed health care”, said Yuri Yourski of ECOM.
             
As if this wasn’t enough, aggressive homophobes frequently seek out gays, bisexual men, trans people and those who promote tolerance toward the LGBT сommunity on social media, threaten them with violence and disseminate their names, contact details and photos on internet-based messaging services with calls to “punish” and kill them. When in danger, these people cannot rely on the police for protection. Reportedly, some aggressive homophobes maintain close relations with homophobic police officers and share information about gays, bisexual men and trans people in order to harm them.
 
AHRCA President Nadejda Atayeva additionally pointed out that “there are cases where police have exploited the fear of being labelled as ‘gay’ by extending the threat of imprisonment under Article 120 beyond gay and bisexual, to heterosexual and pious Muslim men. This is yet another reason why this article, which opens the door to police abuse, has to be repealed.”
 
Additionally, the Uzbekistani authorities severely curtail the right to freedom of expression when it comes to expressions of support for LGBT people and disseminating information about human rights violations affecting them. For example, blogger Miraziz Bazarov was sentenced to three year’s restricted liberty in January 2022 to punish him for peacefully exercising his right to freedom of expression including by voicing solidarity with LGBT people.

His real name is known to the authors of this report but withheld to protect his safety.
       
In recent years, representatives of the Uzbekistani government, the NCHR and the Ombudsperson for Human Rights of the Oliy Majlis (Legislative Chamber of Parliament) have all justified the criminalization of same-sex relations with references to religion, culture, tradition and public opinion, claiming that decriminalization would have negative implications for society and for the country’s reputation in the Muslim world. However, they have failed to acknowledge or address the fact that depriving people of their liberty because of their sexual orientation contradicts the country’s obligations under international human rights law.
 
 
................................
FOR MEDIA ENQUIRIES, PLEASE CONTACT:  
      
Nadejda Atayeva (Russian) 
President, Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA)
Tel.: + 33 6 49 38 86 59; 
 
Yuri Yourski (English, Russian, Ukrainian)
Human Rights Coordinator, Eurasian Coalition on Health, Rights, Gender and Sexual Diversity (ECOM)
Tel.: +372 5397 1573
 
Anne Sunder-Plassmann (English, German, Russian)
Research and Publications Consultant, International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR)
Tel.: +49-40-3863 1458
 
 
 
 

20.4.22

Uzbekistan: Agzam Turgunov continues to be subjected to harassment and intimidation

On 19 April 2022, police came to conduct a search of Agzam Turgunov’s house, but aborted the plan when Turgunov insisted on taking a photo of the search warrant, which contained false information. This is the latest in a series of incidents believed to be aimed at harassing and intimidating the human rights defender and former political prisoner. Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA) and International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) call on the Uzbekistani authorities to end the harassment and intimidation of Agzam Turgunov and to allow him to continue his human rights work unhindered.

On 19 April 2022, at 09.10 am, several police officers (one in uniform, three in plain clothes) came to Agzam Turgunov’s house to conduct a search while the human rights activist was on his way to the Ministry of Justice for a repeat attempt to register the NGO Human Rights House. Turgunov’s son, who refused the officers entry to the house, sent Agzam Turgunov a message urging him to return home. When Turgunov arrived, he insisted on seeing the search warrant. One of the officers, who introduced himself as an investigator of the Department of Internal Affairs of the Almazar District in Tashkent, handed over the document but immediately tore it out of his hands when Turgunov tried to take a photo.

According to Turgunov, the document contained the human rights defender’s home address, the name of his son, who lives at the same address, and is also a co-founder of Human Rights House, and a reference to the criminal case of a named individual who is unknown to Turgunov’s family and has, according to the warrant, been charged with “creation, leadership, participation in religious extremist, separatist, fundamentalist or other prohibited organisations” (under Art. 244-2).

A few moments later, a police officer allegedly told his colleagues that he had received an urgent call from a senior official with instructions to stop the operation. Then the man turned to Turgunov and said: "Sorry, there was a misunderstanding", after which all four officers quickly left.

This was the latest in a recent series of incidents believed to be aimed at harassing and intimidating Agzam Turgunov. Starting from April this year, Turgunov noticed that he was closely observed by police and that a police car was frequently parked outside his house. Furthermore, in the last few months he has been receiving phone calls from the police asking him about his plans for the day and offering “to accompany him”.


BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Agzam Turgunov served three prison terms in connection with his human rights activism. Most recently, he was released in October 2017 after serving nine years in prison. In 2009 and 2014, the European Parliament had called on the Uzbekistani authorities to release Turgunov along with other political prisoners in Uzbekistan.

Since his release, Turgunov and other activists have repeatedly attempted to register the NGO Human Rights House, but to no avail. The Ministry of Justice’s grounds for rejecting the applications have been unclear and unsubstantiated, indicating that the registration requests were refused on politically motivated grounds. In March 2022, Turgunov received another rejection. He is currently updating the package of documents for filing his tenth application for registration.

The space for civil society to operate remains seriously restricted in Uzbekistan. In May 2020, the United Nations Human Rights Committee raised concern at “the small number of independent self-initiated NGOs registered in the State party, [and] the high number of rejections for registration”. On 4 March 2021, President Shavkat Mirziyoyev approved the “Concept on Development of Civil Society in 2021-2025” and a Road Map for its implementation, setting out measures to address various issues important to civil society organisations. However, the Concept fails to address an issue of central importance for independent civil society groups in Uzbekistan, namely the clarification of procedures and criteria that apply when registering NGOs.

 



6.1.22

Joint statement by members of the Civic Solidarity Platform and other NGOs on the alarming situation in Kazakhstan


We, the undersigned members of the Civic Solidarity Platform (CSP) and other NGOs are extremely concerned about the tense situation in Kazakhstan. In the light of rapidly evolving events, we urge all protesters to refrain from the use of violence and the authorities of Kazakhstan to ensure that all their actions taken in response to the protests strictly comply with their obligations under international human rights law and are aimed at de-escalating the situation peacefully.

The current situation evolved after peaceful protests against rising fuel prices in the town of Zhanaozen spread to several other cities across the country, with thousands of people participating and additional demands being voiced by protestors. On 5 January, clashes ensued in Almaty between law enforcement and security forces and protesters, some of which seized government buildings and other public property, including Almaty airport.
 
Late on 5 January, a nation-wide state of emergency was declared in Kazakhstan following the earlier resignation of the government cabinet and a pledge by President Tokayev to use the ‘’harshest possible’’ measures against the protesters. There were reports of shooting, arson and acts of looting in Almaty at night. Yesterday President Tokayev requested assistance from the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), a military alliance between six post-Soviet states in order to combat a threat he classified as “terrorist”, and CSTO peacekeeping forces are reportedly already on their way to Kazakhstan.

According to official information, at least 300 people have been injured, and several dozen police officers and protesters have died during clashes. The exact number of casualties and deaths among protesters is unclear at this time, reinforcing concerns about disproportionate use of force. According to the authorities, over 200 persons have been detained so far during the protests across the country, although observers report that the real figure is much higher. According to observers, detainees have been denied access to lawyers and there are serious concerns about the failure to safeguard their right to due process and fair trials. There have been re-occurring internet outages in the country since yesterday and some journalists have reportedly been detained when carrying out their professional obligations. The well-documented pattern of systematic violations of the right to freedom of peaceful assembly in Kazakhstan reinforces our concerns regarding the current situation.
 
As the situation evolves, we continue to monitor the situation closely. We welcome the appeals for restraint and peaceful solutions made by representatives of the EU, OSCE, UN and other international institutions and foreign governments, and call on protesters to refrain from unlawful measures and on the authorities of Kazakhstan to:
 
— Ensure that the fundamental rights and freedoms of all residents are respected at all times, and that the current situation does not escalate into an armed conflict;
 
— Ensure that their response to the ongoing protests is in strict compliance with international human rights standards, in particular that non-violent means are exhausted in each case before the use of force, and that the use of force is proportionate, damage and injury is minimized and human lives protected;
 
— Respect the right of residents to peaceful assembly, freedom of expression and freedom of association and ensure that any restrictions imposed on these rights meet the requirements of international human rights law, including by distinguishing between peaceful and non-peaceful protest participants;
 
— Ensure that cooperation with CSTO forces is carried out strictly within the framework of international law and does not result in human rights violations;
 
— Provide full information about the number of people who have been detained in connection with the protests in the last few days, as well as where they are held, and ensure that they have prompt access to legal assistance, and that their right to freedom from torture and ill-treatment, due process and fair trials are respected;
 
— Provide full figures of the number of protesters who have been injured and killed, and ensure independent, transparent, prompt and effective investigation into these cases, as well as all cases of the use of force by law enforcement authorities and military resulting in casualties with a view to holding any official responsible for the excessive use of force accountable;
 
— Ensure that any measures taken to investigate and prosecute unlawful actions by protestors are in full accordance with due process requirements and Kazakhstan’s international obligations;
 
— Ensure respect of the right to freedom of information and unhindered access to different means of communication, including the internet;
 
— Refrain from detaining journalists who are covering the events as part of their professional duties and ensure the safety of journalists;
 
— Ensure that civil society representatives are able to monitor the situation without hindrance and allow representatives from the National Preventative Mechanism to visit detained protesters;
 
—Fully cooperate with the OSCE and the UN in resolving the current situation.
 
 
Signatories:

Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (France)
Association UMDPL (Ukraine)
Belarusian Helsinki Committee (Belarus)
Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (Bulgaria)
Centre for Civil Liberties (Ukraine) 
Centre for Participation and Development  (Georgia)
Centre for the Development of Democracy and Human Rights (Russian Federation)
Citizens' Watch (Russian Federation)
Crude Accountability (The United States of America)
DRA (Germany)
Foundation of Regional Initiatives (Ukraine)
Freedom Now (The United States of America)
Georgian Centre For Psychosocial And Medical Rehabilitation Of Torture Victims (GCRT) (Georgia)
Helsinki Citizens' Assembly - Vanadzor  (Armenia)
Helsinki Federation for Human Rights (Poland)
Human Rights Centre (HRC) (Georgia)
Human rights center Viasna (Belarus)
Human Rights Center ZMINA (Ukraine)
Human Rights Club (Azerbaijan)
Human Rights Matter e.V. (Germany)
Human Rights Monitoring Institute (Lithuania) 
Human Rights Movement "Bir Duino-Kyrgyzstan"  (Kyrgyzstan)
Hungarian Helsinki Committee (Hungary)
International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) (Belgium)
KRF Public Alternative (Ukraine)
Lawtrend (Belarus)
Legal Initiative (Belarus)
Libereco Partnership for Human Rights (Germany)
Macedonian Helsinki Committee (North Macedonia)
Netherlands Helsinki Committee (Netherlands)
Norwegian Helsinki Committee (Norway)
Office of Civil Liberties (Tajikistan)
Promo LEX (Moldova)
Protection of Rights without Borders (Armenia)
Public Foundation Notabene (Tajikistan)
Public organization "Dawn" (Tajikistan)
Public Verdict (Russian Federation)
SOVA Center (Russian Federation)
Swedish OSCE-network (Sweden)
Swiss Helsinki Committee (Switzerland)
Truth Hounds (Ukraine)
Vostok SOS (Ukraine)
CIVICUS


22.12.21

Uzbekistan: Conscript Asadbek Fayzullayev died in suspicious circumstances


Asadbek Fayzullayev, a 20-year-old conscript, died in July 2021 while doing military service at an army unit near the city of Termez in southern Uzbekistan on the border with Afghanistan. The authorities claim that he drowned in the Amuzang Channel in Termez District, but his parents and the man who prepared Asadbek’s body for burial  saw fractures, injuries and bruises on his body which were ignored in the forensic examination conducted after his death.

Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA) and International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) are concerned at allegations that Asadbek Fayzullayev had suffered severe physical abuse before he died and that army officers have covered up the circumstances of his death. The organizations call on the Uzbekistani authorities to promptly open an effective investigation into the circumstances of Asadbek’s death and the origin of his fractures and injuries, exhume his body, conduct a thorough forensic medical examination, and bring to justice anyone suspected of being responsible for his death and for covering up the circumstances of his death.

Asadbek was drafted into the army in March 2021. He served in military unit no. 9221 in Termez. Asadbek told his mother during visits that several officers were subjecting him to beatings and other forms of hazing and urged her to ask an influential person in their home town to intervene.

On 26 July 2021, Asadbek’s mother received an SMS from an officer from his unit, saying that Asadbek had left the unit to fetch water and has not returned. The next day she and Asadbek’s younger brother drove to Termez, which is located some 500 kilometres south of their home city of Djizak. When they arrived, military officers said they had still not found Asadbek and took them to a hotel in the city. The next morning, on 28 July, three guards who had been stationed outside their room during the night, told the mother and her younger son to go with them. Some ten minutes later an officer reportedly called Asadbek’s mother and told her that his body had been found in the Amuzang Channel.

Asadbek’s mother insisted on seeing her son’s body. Some 15 military personnel stood around the body on the bank of the Amuzang Channel and reportedly tried to prevent her from inspecting it closely. Asadbek was wearing trousers, boots and a watch, information which appears to contradict the version of events subsequently issued by the military that Asadbek and a fellow-soldier had gone to collect water and decided to go for a swim to cool off in the summer heat. Asadbek’s mother, a former surgical nurse, saw dried blood coming from his mouth; a rib on his left side that appeared to be broken and pointing upwards; that his jaw was bruised on the right side and appeared to be dislocated. She took photos and a short video – which the organizations issuing this document have seen - before the military men took the body away for the autopsy.


Later, on 28 July, Asadbek’s mother and brother went to Sukhardarya Regional Prosecutor’s Office in Termez to file a complaint and request an investigation into the circumstances of her son’s death. She also informed the prosecutor’s office that Asadbek had been subjected to hazing and beating at the military unit. Subsequently, the family sent petitions to the Military Prosecutor’s Office and to the Prosecutor General’s Office, urging them to investigate the circumstances of Asadbek’s death.

On 28 July, Asadbek’s body was transferred to his home town of Djizak for burial. Asadbek’s father arrived in Djizak on 29 July from Moscow, where he had been working. He told AHRCA that by the time he arrived it was almost impossible to recognize Asadbek. His body had been wrapped in cellophane, although it was over 40 degrees Celsius in Djizak. There are allegations that this was done to speed up decomposition and make Asadbek’s injuries less visible.

The man who prepared the body for burial told Asadbek’s father that he found Asadbek’s left hand had been cut in half; with three fingers broken on his right hand; the back of his head had an open wound and his hands and legs were bruised.

On 24 August, Asadbek’s parents went to the Military Prosecutor’s Office in Termez where they were reportedly shown the autopsy document for the first time which concluded that Asadbek drowned and had alcohol in his blood. There was no reference to the fractures and injuries on his body.

On 30 August, the Termez Military Prosecutor’s Office turned down the family’s request to open an investigation into Asadbek’s death, stating that he had drowned and there was no evidence of a crime. Asadbek’s parents continued lodging complaints and calling for an exhumation, but to no avail.



 




20.12.21

Uzbekistan: Prisoner Kadyr Yusupov transferred to an open prison colony


Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA) and International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) welcome the news that the Uzbekistani authorities have finally responded favourably to Kadyr Yusupov’s repeated requests to be moved to an open prison colony. However, we continue to call for his immediate release, in line with the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention’s (UN WGAD)conclusion issued in May 2021. The WGAD found Yusupov’s detention to be arbitrary and called on the authorities to release him immediately, conduct an investigation into the violation of his rights, and provide him with compensation and reparation.

In the morning of 9 December 2021, Kadyr Yusupov was called to the head of Prison Colony No. 4 in the city of Navoi, in southwest Uzbekistan, and told that he would be transferred to a so-called open prison colony, a facility with a less strict prison regime where he can receive an unlimited number of visits. Yusupov was given a few minutes to collect his belongings, then two prison officers accompanied him to the open prison facility (No. 42) in the Zangiata district of Tashkent region.


BACKGROUND INFORMATION

In January 2020, the Military Court of Uzbekistan sentenced Kadyr Yusupov, a former diplomat to Austria, the United Kingdom and the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, to five and a half years’ imprisonment for treason (Article 157 of the Criminal Code) in a closed trial that fell short of international fair trial standards. The case against Yusupov appears to be based on a statement he made during a psychotic episode in December 2018, when he was being treated by medical personnel following a failed suicide attempt in the Tashkent metro. Whilst in hospital, suffering from brain trauma and clearly confused, Yusupov reportedly said that he had been a spy for the West. Kadyr Yusupov has been detained since December 2018. The former diplomat maintains his innocence.

There are credible allegations that state security officers repeatedly threatened Yusupov in pre-trial detention saying that he, his wife and daughter would be raped unless he confessed to the accusations. Yusupov was also denied essential medication and treatment. He filed complaints about the treatment with relevant government agencies. On 3 June 2019, the Prosecutor General’s Office responded that they did not find any evidence of abuse. There are allegations that the investigation was not conducted thoroughly and impartially. In September and October 2021, Yusupov was reportedly beaten by fellow prisoners in Prison Colony No. 4 in Navoi. On 6 December 2021, Yusupov’s lawyer lodged a new complaint with the Prosecutor General’s Office calling for an investigation into the allegations originating during pre-trial detention and the recent beatings.

On 3 May 2021, the UN WGAD concluded that Yusupov’s detention is arbitrary and called on the authorities of Uzbekistan to release him immediately and provide him with adequate compensation. The working group also raised serious concerns about violations of the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules), including the use of prolonged solitary confinement, “deplorable” prison conditions and denial of access to medication and treatment. Other UN bodies and procedures had also raised concern about Yusupov’s case, e.g., the UN Special Rapporteur on torture and the UN Special Rapporteur on health in a joint letter in July 2019, the UN Committee against Torture in its concluding observations adopted in November 2019 and during discussions at the UN Human Rights Committee review in March 2020.





22.11.21

Torture victim Alexander Trofimov still facing criminal charges while his torturers remain at large

Six months after Alexander Trofimov, a 29-year-old father of two, was arrested for theft, the credible allegations that police tortured him in detention have still not been effectively investigated and the alleged perpetrators remain at large. International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) and Association for Human Rights in Central Asia (AHRCA) call on the authorities of Uzbekistan to promptly open an effective investigation into the allegations of torture, bring the perpetrators to justice and present credible evidence to substantiate the allegation of theft or promptly close the criminal case against Trofimov.

“President Mirziyoyev has repeatedly stated that putting a stop to torture is a priority for his government: this case provides the Uzbekistani government with the ideal opportunity to demonstrate that it is serious about this”, said Brigitte Dufour, Director of IPHR. 

On 6 May 2021, Alexander Trofimov was arrested on suspicion of stealing money (Article 169 of the Criminal Code) from a safe belonging to а company in Tashkent. He is believed to have been tortured and ill-treated by police on 6 and 7 May 2021 while being detained at Chilanzar District Police Department (ROVD – Russian acronym) in the capital city of Tashkent without contact with the outside world. Trofimov alleges that four or five police officers kicked him; hit him with truncheons; punched him on the head, body and legs; forced him to do the splits; and took turns to jump on his back while he was handcuffed. Trofimov reportedly begged the officers not to hit him in the head, explaining that he had sustained a skull fracture in 2002. Despite this, RUVD officers reportedly hit him on the site of the injury. Trofimov reported that he subsequently suffered from severe headaches and was unable to sit or move for several days because of severe pain in different parts of his body. 

Two suspects in the same case have confirmed that they witnessed Trofimov being tortured while they were being held at the same detention facility, and that police officers warned they would also be subjected to violence if they did not confess. Police officers reportedly told Trofimov that if he confessed to the theft he would be released, but Trofimov has always maintained his innocence. They also threatened him with violence if he told his lawyer that he had been subjected to abuse. 

Trofimov was only able to meet his lawyer for the first time on 8 May, shortly before the remand hearing. During the hearing the lawyer told the judge that Trofimov had been tortured, showed him photos depicting his injuries, and requested a forensic medical examination. The judge ordered an examination and remanded Trofimov in custody. 

Instead of taking Trofimov to the forensic medical examination shortly after the court hearing, the police officers who were involved in torturing Trofimov reportedly took him to a public health clinic in Chilanzar District. According to Galiya Trofimova, Alexander’s mother, the officers urged the doctors to certify that Trofimov already had bruises on his body when he was arrested. But the doctors refused to provide false evidence. 

The police officers then waited until 10 May – probably in the hope that his injuries would be less visible – before transferring Trofimov to the Main Office of Forensic Medicine of the Ministry of Health for the requested forensic medical examination. Two months later and after several petitions, Galiya Trofimova was able to read the results of the examination at Tashkent City Prosecutor’s Office, but neither she nor the lawyer were able to obtain a copy of the document. According to her, the forensic medical experts only recorded visible injuries – bruises – from torture. They failed to carry out CT or MRI scans to establish whether he had sustained internal injuries. “Police put pressure on the medical forensic experts to ensure that they would not conduct an effective examination fearing that thorough diagnostics would have revealed more than the external bruising”, said Nadejda Atayeva, president of AHRCA. 

After the forensic medical examination police officers again took Trofimov to the public health clinic in Chilanzar District, where doctors conducted an examination and recorded evidence similar to that of the forensic medical doctors. 

On 11 May, Trofimov was taken to the investigation-isolation facility no. 1 in Tashkent (commonly referred to as “Tashtyurma”, Russian for Tashkent prison). There doctors conducted another medical examination, which is a common procedure for new arrivals at the facility. In a letter dated 5 July 2021, the Head of the Prosecutor’s Office of Chilanzar District informed Trofimov’s lawyer that the medical personnel had recorded a large bruise on his left thigh and smaller bruises on his right thigh and his shoulders. They diagnosed that he had a head injury and suffered convulsions, but they did not explain how they came to this conclusion without conducting CT or MRI scans. 

As soon as Galiya Trofimova learnt that her son had been tortured, she sent several complaints to the authorities requesting an investigation, including to the Prosecutor General, the Prosecutor of Chilanzar District and the Ombudsperson for Human Rights of Uzbekistan. 

On 7 June 2021, the Prosecutor General’s Office informed her that it had taken the case “under control”, but it did not open a criminal case. Trofimov’s lawyer has repeatedly urged the Prosecutor General’s Office to open a criminal case into torture or other cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment or punishment under Article 235 of the Criminal Code, but has not received a reply. In the meantime, Tashkent Prosecutor’s Office has been tasked with conducting a preliminary investigation into the allegations, which was later handed down to the Prosecutor’s Office of Chilanzar District and has not produced any results. 

On 12 August 2021, Alexander Trofimov was conditionally released. Shortly afterwards independent medical doctors took an x-ray of his ribs and found a recent fracture. 3 On 21 November Trofimov and his lawyer met with the investigator of the criminal case against Trofimov for the first time in seven months. They learnt that the charge of “theft” was dropped, and that he had instead been charged with “obtaining or selling stolen property” (Article 171 of the Criminal Code) and “failure to report a crime” (Article 241). 

Galiya Trofimova stated: “My son Alexander denies any involvement in the theft and I am convinced he has nothing to do with it. There’s no evidence to suggest that he knew anything about it.”


Recommendations to the Uzbekistani authorities: 

  • Promptly open a criminal case and instigate an effective examination into credible allegations that Alexander Trofimov was tortured and ill-treated after his arrest in May 2021 and that police attempted to fabricate false evidence to escape prosecution, and bring anyone reasonably suspected of being responsible to justice. 
  • Ensure that a second forensic medical examination is conducted thoroughly and impartially.
  • Present sufficient evidence of Trofimov’s participation in the crimes of which he is accused, or swiftly drop all charges against him. 
  • Establish an independent and effective mechanism to receive and investigate allegations of torture and ill-treatment, in line with recommendation 25(b) issued to Uzbekistan by United Nations Human Rights Committee in its March 2020 concluding observations.





19.11.21

NGOs urge the EU to insist on more space for criticism in Central Asia, document key trends ahead of meeting

At the beginning of next week, the European Union (EU) will hold a high-level meeting with the Central Asian governments in Dushanbe, the capital of Tajikistan. A coalition of five NGOs urge the EU to use this meeting to insist on concrete measures to address the unrelenting persecution of government critics; the reprehensible practice of politically-motivated prosecution and imprisonment; wide-ranging restrictions on access to information and free speech; and the repressive civil society environment in Central Asia.

The annual EU-Central Asia Ministerial Meeting is scheduled to take place in Dushanbe on 22 November 2021 with the participation of the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, Joseph Borrell and the foreign ministers of the Central Asian countries. At the meeting, the EU and the Central Asian governments will discuss different areas of cooperation, including cooperation on promoting human rights, the rule of law and democratic governance.
  
Ahead of the meeting, International Partnership for Human Rights, Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law, the Legal Prosperity Foundation, Turkmen Initiative for Human Rights and the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia have prepared a briefing paper documenting current key human rights concerns in the five Central Asian countries, which they urge the EU to raise with its Central Asian partners.
  
The joint NGO briefing paper documents how the Central Asian authorities continue to impose excessive restrictions on fundamental freedoms and implement harsh measures to prevent scrutiny and criticism of state policies as they battle with the fallout of the Covid-19 pandemic, economic and social challenges, and renewed security concerns arising from the recent developments in Afghanistan. Major, alarming trends covered in the paper include:
  
Persecution of government critics: Across the region, government critics are subjected to intimidation and harassment ranging from orchestrated online attacks, anonymous threats and surveillance to being summoned, prosecuted and convicted on trumped-up charges.
   
As Kyrgyzstan has taken an increasingly authoritarian turn following last year’s political crisis and President Sadyr Japarov’s rise to power, outspoken activists, journalists and lawyers have faced increased threats and harassment. Those targeted particularly include critics of the new controversial constitution, which significantly increased the president’s powers without providing for adequate checks and balances and reduced the role of parliament, due to be elected this month, more than a year after the cancellation of the results of the previous elections.
  
Despite President Shavkat Mirziyoyev’s pledges to promote democratic reform, the October 2021 presidential elections in Uzbekistan featured no genuine competition. Prior to the elections, opposition parties were denied registration and opposition members, bloggers and other government critics faced renewed pressure and harassment. This worrisome development continues after the elections, in which Mirziyoyev, as expected, was re-elected for a second term.
                
Under President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, who came to power in 2019, the authorities in Kazakhstan continue to suppress political opposition and crack down on government critics. The authorities have particularly stepped up their campaign against people accused of participating in or supporting opposition movements banned as purportedly ‘’extremist’’, holding them to account for peaceful actions of expression and protest.
   
The authorities of Turkmenistan have targeted dissidents both at home and abroad as part of a widening crackdown unleashed in response to growing expressions of discontent on social media and during protests held by diaspora communities. Any citizen who openly criticises the situation in the closed country, ruled by President Gurbanguly Berdymukhamedov, risks repercussions, as do their relatives.
   
Under the entrenched authoritarian rule of President Emomali Rahmon in Tajikistan, persecution of members of the political opposition is ongoing. Independent journalists, and lawyers continue to be targeted by intimidation and reprisals for their work on politically sensitive issues and cases.
  
Pattern of politically motivated persecution and imprisonment: The ongoing pattern of politically motivated prosecution and imprisonment of activists, journalists and lawyers following unfair trials is of serious concern across the region.
   
In Kazakhstan, a prominent victim of this practice, poet-dissident Aron Atabek was released in October 2021 after spending more than 15 years in prison. His harsh prison experience has taken a heavy toll, leaving him seriously debilitated, and shortly after his release he was hospitalised in intensive care due to Covid-19 related pneumonia. He remains in a critical condition.
   
The authorities of Kyrgyzstan have to date failed to ensure an impartial and effective investigation into last year’s death in prison of human rights defender Azimjan Askarov, and no one has been held accountable for this tragic outcome. Askarov died due to Covid-19 related pneumonia after unjustly spending ten years behind bars. The authorities recently reopened the investigation into his death, but serious concerns about its nature remain.
   
In Tajikistan, lawyer Buzurgmehr Yorov continues to serve a lengthy prison sentence, which was handed down to him in closed and unfair proceedings after he defended high-ranking opposition members in 2015. His co-defendant, lawyer Nuriddin Mahkamov also remains in prison on charges considered politically motivated.
  
In Turkmenistan, journalist Nurgeldy Khalykov was imprisoned last year in retaliation for his cooperation with a Turkmenistan-covering organisation based in exile, while doctor Khursanai Ismatullaeva was prosecuted this summer after seeking help from exile-based human rights groups in her struggle to obtain justice for her unfair dismissal from a medical clinic. The authorities have also sought the return of activists based abroad, putting them at a serious risk of prosecution and imprisonment on trumped-up charges and other rights violations if returned.
  
In Uzbekistan, blogger Miraziz Bazarov is facing trumped-up criminal charges after criticising the lack of transparency in the government’s use of Covid-19 related loans and the double standards amongst officials in relation to LGBTI people. Another blogger, Otabek Sattoriy was imprisoned earlier this year on charges believed to have been fabricated to punish him for speaking out on corruption among local officials.
  
The individuals mentioned above are only a few of those who have been prosecuted and imprisoned on politically motivated charges in the region; there are many other victims of this practice, too.
             
Withholding information of public interest and restricting free speech: The Central Asian authorities continue to prevent access to information on issues of public importance, including public health issues in the context of the global Covid-19 pandemic. This problem has been particularly prevalent in Turkmenistan, whose government has consistently denied and covered up the national Covid-19 outbreak throughout the pandemic. The Tajikistani government has also failed to adopt a transparent approach about the pandemic, claiming victory over it earlier this year and denying the occurrence of new Covid-19 cases for months before being forced to admit that there was a new wave.
The pattern of muzzling independent media continues and the Central Asian authorities use various tactics to obstruct the dissemination and exchange of information critical of those in power on online platforms. The authorities have blocked access to independent news sites, social media and other internet resources and initiated other measures restricting the operation of online resources, using arguments such as national security concerns, personal data considerations, and the protection of children.
 
The Central Asian authorities have also misused the fight against ‘’disinformation” to restrict legitimate free speech on and offline. In Kazakhstan, a pre-existing criminal code provision on “knowingly disseminating false information” has been used to stifle criticism, along with other overly broad criminal charges. In Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan, new vaguely worded legislation banning the dissemination of “false’’ information has been enacted with negative implications especially in relation to online discussions. The Turkmenistani authorities consider any information challenging the government narrative “false” and seek to prevent access to such information through internet censorship and intimidation.
  
Repressive civil society environment: The operating environment for civil society organisations remains highly challenging across the region. Excessive state oversight of NGOs is an ongoing problem, and it is of particular concern that legislation setting out financial reporting obligations might be implemented in a way that restricts the legitimate activities of NGOs. For example, ahead of the January 2021 parliamentary elections, leading human rights NGOs in Kazakhstan were threatened with suspension because of alleged minor, technical mistakes made when reporting about foreign grants. The recent adoption of legislation introducing a new financial reporting scheme for NGOs in Kyrgyzstan has prompted concerns that a similar scenario might occur there. The Tajikistani authorities have arbitrarily applied tax legislation to harass independent civil society organisations, requiring them to pay income tax on foreign grants, although this is not provided for by law.
  
Contrary to its commitment to improve the operating space for civil society, the Uzbekistani government continues to deny compulsory state registration to newly established, independent NGOs on technical and unsubstantiated grounds. For example, the NGO Human Rights House was denied registration for the eighth time in August 2021, and the following month a local court refused to review the group’s complaint against the government’s refusal to register it. No independent human rights NGOs are able to operate inside Turkmenistan, and the clandestine contributors of exile-based NGOs work at great risk. Exile-based groups have also been subjected to pressure, including inference with their website operations and social media content takedowns due to government abuse of mechanisms for reporting copyright violations.
  
Across the region, human rights NGOs face widespread mistrust, with arguments about defending national security and so-called traditional values being used by decisionmakers, aggressively-minded activists and online trolls to stigmatise, discredit and intimidate groups advocating for the rights of women, LGBT and other vulnerable groups.
  
More information about these and other current trends in the five countries of the region can be found by downloading the full paper, entitled No space for criticism: Excessive restrictions on fundamental rights in Central Asia.